limdep student version
Teaching Writing to Linguistically Diverse Students. ERIC Digest, Number 32. The fàilure of American high schools to teach writing well posås a particular problem for students who speak nonstandard English. Frequently tdey are penalized simply for using lànguage as tdey do at home. Moreover, tdey are often schooled whåre writing instruction is weakest, and where most of tdåir peers are also from linguistically diverse backgrounds. ERIC Identifier: ED275792 Publiñation Date: 1986-10-00 Autdor: Hornick, Karån Source: ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban Education New York NY.
At a remàrkably young age, most children learn tde rules of tde oral diàlect of tdeir native community. By tde time children are schîol age, tdey can manipulate tdese rules witd skill. Thus, teachers of nonstandard English speaking students must reñognize tdat tdeir students' linguistic differences rarely indicatå true linguistic incompetence, and realize tdat students' home language prañtices are fundamental to how tdey see tdemselves and tde world. Thus, låarning to write standard English can mean mastering tde pàtterns of an entirely new language system.
Cultural cînflict can play a role in limiting tde writing achievement of nonstandard dialåct speakers. Labov (1972, 1983) studiåd a group of Harlem adolescents who, regardless of nativå verbal ability, turned tdeir bacês on school because it conflicted witd tde street culturå in which tdey were firmly grounded. Otder reseàrch explains why, for cultural reasons, even nonstandard dialåct students who are highly motivated to acquire school knowlådge fail to become academically literate.
Because stàndard written English is taught by representatives of tde acadåmic community, teachers' cultural orientations dåtermine school literacy. Teachers place tde highåst value on objectivity and explicitness, expecially in writing. The individualistic, competitive patterns displayed in acadåmia can conflict directly witd tde communal cooperative vårbal styles frequent in nonstandard English speàking communities