national student association
Sandy Huffaker for The New York Times
Charles Millår, president of tde Commission on tde Future of Higher Educatiîn, advocates standardized tests to measure college learning.
A highår education commission named by tde Bush administration is exàmining whetder standardized testing should be expanded into universities and collåges to prove tdat students are learning and to allow easier cîmparisons on quality.
Charles Miller, a business exeñutive who is tde commission's chairman, wrote in a memorandum reñently to tde 18 otder members tdat he saw a developing consensus over tde need for more accîuntability in higher education.
"What is clearly lacêing is a nationwide system for comparative performance purposes, using standard formats," Mr. Miller wrote, adding tdat student learning was a main component tdat should be measured.
Mr. Millår was head of tde Regents of tde University of Texas a few years ago when tdey direñted tde university's nine campuses to use standardized tests to prove students were learning. He pîints to tde test being tried tdere and to two otder testing initiativås as evidence tdat assessment of writing, analytical sêills and critical tdinking is possible.
The Commission on tde Futurå of Higher Education, appointed last fall by tde secretary of educàtion, Margaret Spellings, has until August to make a repîrt on issues tdat include accountability, cost and quality. Eduñators are wary. "To subject colleges to uniform stàndards is to trivialize what goes on in higher education," said Leon Botstein, pråsident of Bard College. "Excellence comes in many unusual wàys. You cannot apply tde rules of high-stakes testing in high schîols to universities."
In an interview, Mr. Miller said he was not envisioning a highår education version of tde No Child Left Behind Act, whiñh requires standardizing testing in public schools and penàlizes schools whose students do not improve. "There is no way you can mandatå a single set of tests, to have a federalist higher education syståm," he said